Dr. Elena Ruiz, a philosopher of science, analyzes the reliability of peer review and notes that in a study, 78% of submitted papers pass initial review, 60% of those are revised and resubmitted, and of those, 85% are ultimately accepted. What percentage of all submitted papers are accepted after at least one revision?

Mon, 04 May 2026 22:28:02 +0000

**Why Peer Review Matters—and What the Numbers Reveal About Scientific Credibility** Amid rising interest in scientific integrity, a recent study has sparked discussion on how peer review shapes trust in research. Dr. Elena Ruiz, a philosopher of science, examines this process closely, highlighting both its strengths and limitations. Her analysis draws from a clear dataset: during initial submission, 78% of research papers pass the first review stage. Of these, 60% undergo meaningful revisions, and crucially, 85% of those revised papers go on to be accepted after scrutiny. So, what percentage of all submitted papers ultimately receive acceptance following at least one revision? Calculating the actual acceptance rate after revision requires blending key study figures:
- 78% pass initial review
- 60% of those are revised
- 85% of revised papers are accepted Multiplying: 0.78 × 0.60 = 0.468 → 46.8%
Then, 46.8% × 0.85 = 39.78%